BigCommerce vs Shopify: an honest comparison for DTC and B2B stores

BigCommerce vs Shopify is closer than most comparisons admit. Both are hosted SaaS platforms, both handle security, hosting and scaling for you, and both run large stores. The difference is philosophy: Shopify keeps the core lean and relies on its huge app ecosystem, while BigCommerce builds more features into the platform itself and is more open about payment gateways. As a rule of thumb, I point direct-to-consumer brands toward Shopify and B2B sellers or merchants with large, complex catalogs toward BigCommerce. I build on both, so here is the detail behind that rule.

BigCommerce vs Shopify comparison table

I have left plan prices out on purpose. Both platforms change pricing and plan features often enough that any number I write here would go stale; check their current pricing pages, and compare the plan you would actually need rather than the entry plan.

BigCommerce vs Shopify fees: how the pricing models differ

The two cost models reward different businesses.

Shopify charges a monthly plan, payment processing fees, and, at the time of writing, an additional transaction fee on each order if you use a third-party gateway instead of Shopify Payments. If Shopify Payments is available in your country and your business, the extra fee disappears. If you need a specific gateway (a particular acquirer, a high-risk processor, or a bank-negotiated rate), that fee adds up. Then there are apps: a mature Shopify store commonly runs a stack of paid apps, and those subscriptions are a real line item.

BigCommerce does not charge platform transaction fees on any supported gateway, so you can shop around for processing rates. The catch is its plan model: each plan has an annual online sales threshold, based on trailing twelve-month sales, and when you pass it you are moved to the next plan. Fast-growing stores should model where that lands, because a jump in sales means a jump in platform cost. At higher volumes you end up on Enterprise with custom pricing.

In practice: high volume on a third-party gateway leans BigCommerce; a store happy with Shopify Payments and a modest app stack leans Shopify.

Built-in features vs apps

BigCommerce includes more out of the box: customer groups with group pricing, faceted search, rich product options and modifiers, multi-currency, and bulk pricing rules. Fewer apps means fewer monthly subscriptions, fewer third-party scripts slowing pages down, and fewer vendors to depend on.

Shopify's approach is a lean, extremely polished core plus the largest ecommerce app ecosystem there is. Almost anything you want exists as an app, usually with good documentation and support. The cost is that functionality is spread across vendors, each with its own pricing and script weight, and removing an app does not always clean up everything it added to your theme.

If you like picking best-of-breed tools, Shopify's model is a feature. If you want fewer moving parts, BigCommerce's is.

BigCommerce vs Shopify for B2B

This is where the difference is clearest. BigCommerce has invested heavily in B2B, and its B2B Edition covers what wholesale buyers expect: company accounts with multiple buyers and roles, a buyer portal, quote requests and negotiation, purchase orders and payment on account, shopping lists and quick reorder, and customer-specific price lists. For a manufacturer or distributor selling to trade accounts, that is a lot of functionality you would otherwise assemble from apps or custom code.

Shopify has closed much of the gap with native B2B on Shopify Plus: company profiles with locations, B2B-specific catalogs and price lists, payment terms, quantity rules and a combined DTC and wholesale store. For a brand that is mainly DTC with a wholesale channel on the side, Shopify Plus B2B is often enough. For a business where B2B is the main channel, with complex account hierarchies, quotes and ERP-driven pricing, I usually find BigCommerce the easier fit.

Multi-storefront and international selling

BigCommerce Multi-Storefront lets you run several storefronts (different brands, regions or a separate wholesale site) from one admin, with a shared catalog and per-storefront settings. The number of storefronts depends on your plan.

Shopify handles international selling mainly through Shopify Markets: local currencies, languages, domains or subfolders, and market-specific pricing within one store. For genuinely separate brands, Shopify Plus merchants use expansion stores, which are separate stores administered individually, with syncing handled by apps or integrations. If your need is "one brand, many countries", Shopify Markets is excellent. If it is "several brands, one catalog", BigCommerce's model is tidier.

Headless: Catalyst vs Hydrogen

Both platforms are strong headless backends with GraphQL storefront APIs.

• BigCommerce offers Catalyst, a Next.js-based storefront maintained by BigCommerce, on top of its GraphQL Storefront API. It is a good fit if your team already works in Next.js and wants to host on Vercel or its own infrastructure.
• Shopify offers Hydrogen, its React-based framework, with Oxygen as built-in hosting, on top of the Storefront API. The tooling is mature and tightly integrated with Shopify's checkout and markets.

Headless is worth it when you need custom front-end experiences, content-heavy storefronts or very specific performance targets. It is not worth it just to be modern: you take on a second codebase and its hosting. If you do go headless, my Next.js development work covers Catalyst and custom storefronts, and I explain the API trade-offs in GraphQL vs REST.

Themes and SEO

Shopify's theme marketplace is far larger, and Online Store 2.0 sections make it easy for non-developers to build pages. BigCommerce's Stencil themes and Page Builder are capable, but the choice is smaller, and custom Stencil work needs a developer comfortable with Handlebars.

For SEO, both handle the essentials: editable titles and meta descriptions, canonical tags, sitemaps, redirects and clean HTTPS. BigCommerce gives more control over URL structure, so you can use /blue-shirt/ rather than being locked into /products/blue-shirt. Shopify's fixed prefixes are rarely a ranking problem in themselves, but they matter during a migration and for sites with strict URL conventions. In both cases, redirects from old URLs are essential when you move; see my zero-downtime migration guide.

Who should choose which

Choose Shopify if

• You are a DTC brand and want the checkout shoppers already trust, including Shop Pay.
• You sell in person as well as online and want native POS.
• You want the largest pool of themes, apps and developers.
• Shopify Payments is available to you, so the third-party gateway fee does not apply.

Choose BigCommerce if

• B2B or wholesale is a primary channel, not an add-on.
• You have a large catalog with complex options, customer groups and price lists.
• You need a specific payment gateway and want to avoid platform transaction fees.
• You want several storefronts from one admin, or more control over URLs.

If you are also weighing a self-hosted option, my Shopify vs WooCommerce comparison covers that trade-off.

When it is worth getting help

For a straightforward DTC store, either platform will serve you well and the table above should settle it. It is worth talking to someone when B2B, multiple storefronts, ERP integration or a migration with years of SEO history is involved, because those are expensive to get wrong. My BigCommerce development service covers store builds, Stencil themes, B2B setup and migrations, and my Shopify development service covers the same on Shopify, so I have no stake in which one you choose. Small jobs are $20/hour; defined projects get a fixed price agreed in writing. If you want a second opinion on building on BigCommerce versus Shopify for your catalog, send me the details.

Frequently asked questions